Last night, some of the most well-known models in the world walked in the 2018 Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show. For the first time in three years, the show took place in the U.S., bringing some of the biggest A-list celebrities to the heart of New York City. As expected, the models were doused in a sea of wings, capes, and crystal-adorned lingerie while walking alongside performers such as Shawn Mendes and Rita Ora, just to name a few.

Familiar faces in the VS Angel squad made predictably notable appearances, like Candice Swanepoel and Taylor Hill, but it was the newcomers we were most excited to see have their VS moment, including Duckie Thot, Kelsey Merritt, and Winnie Harlow. While nearly every outfit in the show was a spectacle of its own, we rounded up the 23 that stood out to us the most, including our favorite looks modeled by the new kids on the block.